Welcome to Gaia! :: View User's Journal | Gaia Journals

 
 

View User's Journal

Suspension of Disbelief (perpetual)
Herein lie secrets old and new; spanning countless of eons and legions of symbolic deaths. Shall, beyond this click, be an abyss of meaningless words and ever-important concepts that keep the human race properly in proportion.
Gaian Cash—why would you do it?
I understand Gaiaonline.com implementing the Gaia Cash system into the network. Aside from advertisement, it is the only other path to profit. And what a profit it is.

Currently, we have around 19,200,000 registered users. Let us say, pessimistically, that one (which is no doubt actually much larger) in every five-thousand purchases Gaia Cash. That's around 4,000 users. Now let us say that each spends ten dollars (which is, again, very pessimistic). That's forty-thousand dollars. Annually, that would be an okay number; but I hope we can all agree on that it's far from an annual sort of thing. I'll give you another pessimistic number: $40,000 a month. That's right. If four thousand users purchase Gaia Cash each month, that's $40k. Let me remind you, again, that I used very pessimistic numbers. It could easily be $100k.

So, yes, I understand why the owners of Gaia did this. Although, honestly, advertisement on a site with nearly twenty million users brings in so much more money than you can imagine. I think this is the second largest forum-based website in the world. (A category to which facebook and myspace do not belong to—as they are much, much larger and focus on social networking, not unlike twitter.)

Furthermore, Gaia Interactive, Inc.—which owns Gaiaonline.com—is a private company. Meaning that they do not have shareholders. All profits head straight to the founder. That's a lot of money.

But, enough about that.

What I do not understand, however, is how people can live with themselves after spending hard-earned (in most cases) money on mere pixels that never redeem themselves for anything worthwhile. You spend dollars (most likely your parents', as most users on here are children), you buy a bundle, you exchange it for Gaia Gold, and then you purchase colorful items for your avatar. If you cut the first three steps, it's perfectly acceptable. But, overall, it is not.

One can make millions without having to spend real money. And I bet it would feel like much more of an accomplishment. Actually, I don't understand what's the big deal about really expensive items if you haven't earned them. It's an empty gesture, really. In most cases, cheap items look just as good, sometimes better than, the more expensive ones.

Additionally, having spent that real money, you spend extraordinary amounts of time on the site itself. So, you or your parents lose money, you lose your time—and you get absolutely nothing to show for it.

Now, I'm not saying that Gaiaonline is useless. On the contrary, some portions are amazing. The Extended Discussion and Writers Forum, for example. Those prompt intelligent discussions—where one can spent one's desire for verbal challenge.

In short, wasting time on Gaia is understandable. Wasting time and money is not. You leeches.

Thank you.

I don't expect any comments. A bit too long for an average user to bother with.





Triple Dare
Community Member
Triple Dare
Prev | Next
Archive | Home

  • 09/20/09 to 09/13/09 (1)

  • User Comments: [20]
    AlternativeTrouble
    Community Member





    Tue Sep 15, 2009 @ 12:54am


    I agree.


    Triple Dare
    Community Member





    Tue Sep 15, 2009 @ 02:02am


    Why thank you.


    zen traveler
    Community Member





    Sun Sep 20, 2009 @ 04:59am


    tl;dr
    Just kidding.

    First off, might I mention that you still need to add the variable of payroll to your pessimistic formula. Each programmer, artist, and administrator (among a few other roles) who works for Gaia Interactive, Inc. requires a salary for working within that company. Which, when you factor in the amount of people working for said company, subtracts quite a bit of money from your total pessimistic amount of $100k. However, you are right in your assumption that Gaia makes a lot more money than that. And yet they continue to seek more money, even to the point where they seem to have lost their supposed care for their users.

    I also agree in your interpretation of wasting money on Gaia. Personally, I enjoy my avatar, and the items on it. Items that took maybe a few days of posting and polling to obtain the money for. I have never purchased Gaia Cash, and nor do I ever plan on it, and here's why:
    1. I have better things to spend my money on. I am 18 years old, and I stopped getting money from my parents a few years ago. I would rather spend the money that I put sweat and tears into on things that matter; heat, food for my cat, food for myself, gas, etc.
    2. I again agree with your opinion, in that items obtained by such simple means do not have as much value as items that you strived and saved for. I saved up for my Coco plushie; 9 year old Kyle had his mother buy it for him. While he may love his Coco, when he sees the new Grunny doll, he will flip. I will not however, because I wanted my doll for months, finally obtained it, and am now satisfied.

    I digress. tl;dr: I agree with you whole-heartedly.


    Darth stankface
    Community Member





    Sun Sep 20, 2009 @ 04:37pm


    ...I read the whole thing.
    xD
    I agree.
    Time is acceptable, manage it as you will. But money.
    I think not.


    Siren the Valkyrie
    Community Member





    Fri Sep 25, 2009 @ 10:07pm


    Compelling argument and you are completely correct.

    Unfortunately, some of use are too stupid (guilty) and see shiny and go nuts.

    But they have made it harder to turn Gaia Cash into Gaia Gold.

    If you purchase with your pay pal, everything you buy with that cash is frozen for 7 days.

    The bottom line is that I'm a tad on the lazy side, and the truth is that I was completely against spending my cash, until I did it the first time.

    It's only like 5 at a time, but still, I feel like I'm on cocaine.


    xXmoreelenXx
    Community Member





    Mon Sep 28, 2009 @ 02:55pm


    I concur.


    Prince Rilian
    Community Member





    Tue Sep 29, 2009 @ 10:57pm


    I read the first 2 paragraphs.
    after that, tl;dr


    Bibbly
    Community Member





    Wed Sep 30, 2009 @ 08:12pm


    If this is indeed too long for the 'average user' to 'bother with' then I fear for the foundations. (the forums)

    What am I saying... they've almost been completely condemned.
    Even with developers implementing faster ways at getting Gaea gold, some folks still troll and act like dorks.


    It's a purchase without a product.
    Woo hoo?

    And I don't know about the ED being all too intelligent. Maybe if you navigate to a specific sub forum, sure, yeah it could/can be.

    My journal says just about the same thing.
    Maybe not all in one entry. But fo sho yo.
    Journal Entry about G.C.
    Look for: [08/10/09 04:15pm]


    Sweetpea The Tigress
    Community Member





    Thu Oct 01, 2009 @ 09:45pm


    Occasionally I waste $5.00 on Gaia in order to buy stupid pixels to have fun... *runs away and hides, full of guilt*


    sophia vader
    Community Member





    Sat Oct 03, 2009 @ 12:23am


    I AGREE 150% ^ . <


    Courage The CowardIy Dog
    Community Member





    Tue Oct 06, 2009 @ 04:57pm


    Ya why spend hard earned money on some pixal's.
    Thats just bullshit.


    Vertigris
    Community Member





    Mon Oct 12, 2009 @ 05:05pm


    I agree with you fully. What a greedy and ridiculous thing Gaia Cash is. Some people are so concerned with forging an impressive visual "e-dentity" that they are willing to do anything to get their metaphorical "hands" on items, so to speak. It's ludicrous.

    For the record, cheap items DO often look better, but I think that it's the prestige of a rare and "expensive" item that users aim for.

    rolleyes


    Eteles
    Community Member





    Fri Oct 16, 2009 @ 01:58am


    I agree with you on many points, but feel that the right decision as to whether to use the cash shop ultimately depends on the person in question.

    For an extreme, but illustrative, example, imagine this: You are an overworked accountant, and your life's passion is Gaia and its pixel items. For no reason you can understand, they make you deliriously happy in a way no other pleasure can compare to. You're a sensible person in all other ways, but Gaia and its items are your one 'frivolous pleasure.'

    You see the most beautiful item imaginable in the cash shop; it makes your heart flutter to see it, and you would feel even happier if you were able to equip it and post around the site with it. You know this from experience. You do not want any other, similar items Gaia offers with the same intensity; for whatever reason (or, more accurately, no reason,) you want THAT ONE, and the desire does not fade or diminish within a matter of weeks or months.

    However, you hate posting and games, are ashamed to beg donations, and feel that playing the market is unethical. It would make you unhappy if you had to do any of those things to get the gold to buy it on the market place.

    The item costs ten bucks. You quickly calculate that you spend that much in lattes in a week, then decide to replace the lattes with the free coffee at the office and get the item. You do it, and feel deliriously happy traipsing around Gaia as a result; each extra moment you spend there, you spend because you are having fun and being happy. Being an otherwise sensible person, you do not allow it to cut into other meaningful areas of your life - you just have fun with it.

    For a person such as this, I don't see how buying pixels is any worse than buying, for example, candy. It's a ridiculously simple pleasure, and any negative side effects of indulging might be worth it to you simply because it makes you happy.

    For other people, I think it depends on how similar you are to the person I described. If you're not sensible enough to manage your recreation time wisely, if you don't have money to spare, if you enjoy getting gaia gold without paying real money, and if you don't gain happiness from buying pixel items, using the cash shop is a bad decision.

    I do fit all of the qualifiers in that list (except maybe the 'enjoy getting gold' one,) so the cash shop is definitely out for me. But for someone who has the opposite traits, or even one or a few of those traits to a strong enough degree, I think that buying from the cash shop could make sense.

    We buy a lot of things that are useless except for the fact that they make us happy because they're pretty or we get to show them off or collecting them just feels satisfying. Some people even like the feeling of spending money. As happiness is completely subjective, how can we say that that's stupid? People need fun. If cash shop items are your ideal way to get it, I say go for it.

    If what I've said above is sensible, and cash shop items are a product that some people might want and enjoy responsibly, then Gaia's use of the cash shop might be good for all of Gaia, too. (Key word: might.) I strongly suspect that some of the money Gaia gets from the cash shop goes to improving Gaia as a whole. They could be using the money to hire more staff, for example, and those staff might be working on things other than the cash shop as well as on cash items - things like fixing bugs and making free features.

    Why would they do this? Because it makes the site more desirable as a whole, which makes it more likely that they will attract users who will want to buy cash items.

    Is it pure altruism? No. But I don't think it's pure evil, either, and it might even be moral in an Objectivist kind of way.

    I'd never use it myself, but I like the cash shop. I just hope that Gaians are responsible enough to use it well. Evolutionary Items, certainly, are a gamble which remind me of lottery tickets... if you lose as much happiness when you don't win as you gained when you bought the ticket, it's not a good purchase. But some people really like to gamble that way, and don't mind losing as much as they like dreaming about what they'd do with the money if lightning strikes.


    In Living Colour
    Community Member





    Wed Nov 11, 2009 @ 09:39pm


    you do make a really valid point. Why do people spend actual money on something that isn't real. well lots of people do and it is kinda dumb but it could be for entertainment because in some cases that is why people go on the computer/gaia


    oraclefire
    Community Member





    Tue Dec 15, 2009 @ 07:35am


    Wow intresting point of veiw. I do agree. I get the time aspet. I mean the avis are pretty cool but not so much worth me spending hard earned money on.


    Cafekko Glitch
    Community Member





    Wed Jan 27, 2010 @ 07:34pm


    I think it's too expensive too -_-"

    I think you should earn it when you do something cool or get 50 gaia cash every 10000 gold you get.


    13litz
    Community Member





    Wed Feb 24, 2010 @ 03:21am



          Now Eteles was tl;dr.

          Here's my late -and rather informal- say on such a thought provoking entry.
          This is quiet the argument you have here. I would speculate that the more inclined people are to spend time on the internet and accordingly, Gaia, the more tempted they are to yield to their... I suppose, fickle wants. It can be treated as a hobby to some degree.
          And if Gaia is such a company then they've done exceedingly well with the business, don't you think? I give them my compliments for tapping into this source of revenue.

          I don't plan to begin rioting until they raise the prices to the point where it becomes ridiculous or unfair. The site keeps me entertained and shelling out a few dollars every so often to highlight the experience isn't too cruel of an arrangement. Tho admittedly I have better priorities. Having said that, it can be assumed that humanity has yet to reach those catastrophic levels of stupidity and that kids do grow up.




    The Fiery Fiddler
    Community Member





    Mon Mar 22, 2010 @ 08:25pm


    I agree with you wholeheartedly. It's just silly to waste real money on a virtual world. I may be the world's most frugal teenager, but if one thinks on it logically, the same conclusion comes.


    Ora the Owlish
    Community Member





    Wed Mar 31, 2010 @ 12:54am


    Somehow I managed to double-post...my bad. redface


    Ora the Owlish
    Community Member





    Wed Mar 31, 2010 @ 12:56am


    Hah, I clicked into this from your sig (not just because I'm a sheep; mostly because I love reading a well-done journal) and I'd really like to applaud you for this bit! You did a very thorough job with your argument and brought up all the points (and a few more) that I tend to use in my own defense of playing Cash free.


    User Comments: [20]
     
     
    Manage Your Items
    Other Stuff
    Get GCash
    Offers
    Get Items
    More Items
    Where Everyone Hangs Out
    Other Community Areas
    Virtual Spaces
    Fun Stuff
    Gaia's Games
    Mini-Games
    Play with GCash
    Play with Platinum